In some cases the vwait command may not return immediately after varName is set. This happens if the event handler that sets varName does not complete immediately. For example, if an event handler sets varName and then itself calls vwait to wait for a different variable, then it may not return for a long time. During this time the top-level vwait is blocked waiting for the event handler to complete, so it cannot return either. (See the NESTED VWAITS BY EXAMPLE below.)
To be clear, multiple vwait calls will nest and will not happen in parallel. The outermost call to vwait will not return until all the inner ones do. It is recommended that code should never nest vwait calls (by avoiding putting them in event callbacks) but when that is not possible, care should be taken to add interlock variables to the code to prevent all reentrant calls to vwait that are not strictly necessary. Be aware that the synchronous modes of operation of some Tcl packages (e.g., http) use vwait internally; if using the event loop, it is best to use the asynchronous callback-based modes of operation of those packages where available.
vwait forever
Wait five seconds for a connection to a server socket, otherwise close the socket and continue running the script:
# Initialise the state
after 5000 set state timeout
set server [socket -server accept 12345]
proc accept {args} {
global state connectionInfo
set state accepted
set connectionInfo $args
}
# Wait for something to happen
vwait state
# Clean up events that could have happened
close $server
after cancel set state timeout
# Do something based on how the vwait finished...
switch $state {
timeout {
puts "no connection on port 12345"
}
accepted {
puts "connection: $connectionInfo"
puts [lindex $connectionInfo 0] "Hello there!"
}
}
A command that will wait for some time delay by waiting for a namespace variable to be set. Includes an interlock to prevent nested waits.
namespace eval example {
variable v done
proc wait {delay} {
variable v
if {$v ne "waiting"} {
set v waiting
after $delay [namespace code {set v done}]
vwait [namespace which -variable v]
}
return $v
}
}
When running inside a coroutine, an alternative to using vwait is to yield to an outer event loop and to get recommenced when the variable is set, or at an idle moment after that.
coroutine task apply {{} {
# simulate [after 1000]
after 1000 [info coroutine]
yield
# schedule the setting of a global variable, as normal
after 2000 {set var 1}
# simulate [vwait var]
proc updatedVar {task args} {
after idle $task
trace remove variable ::var write "updatedVar $task"
}
trace add variable ::var write "updatedVar [info coroutine]"
yield
}}
after 500 {
puts "waiting for b"
vwait b
puts "b was set"
}
after 1000 {
puts "setting a"
set a 10
}
puts "waiting for a"
vwait a
puts "a was set"
puts "setting b"
set b 42
If you run the above code, you get this output:
waiting for a waiting for b setting a
The script will never print “a was set” until after it has printed “b was set” because of the nesting of vwait commands, and yet b will not be set until after the outer vwait returns, so the script has deadlocked. The only ways to avoid this are to either structure the overall program in continuation-passing style or to use coroutine to make the continuations implicit. The first of these options would be written as:
after 500 {
puts "waiting for b"
trace add variable b write {apply {args {
global a b
trace remove variable ::b write \
[lrange [info level 0] 0 1]
puts "b was set"
set ::done ok
}}}
}
after 1000 {
puts "setting a"
set a 10
}
puts "waiting for a"
trace add variable a write {apply {args {
global a b
trace remove variable a write [lrange [info level 0] 0 1]
puts "a was set"
puts "setting b"
set b 42
}}}
vwait done
The second option, with coroutine and some helper procedures, is done like this:
# A coroutine-based wait-for-variable command
proc waitvar globalVar {
trace add variable ::$globalVar write \
[list apply {{v c args} {
trace remove variable $v write \
[lrange [info level 0] 0 3]
after 0 $c
}} ::$globalVar [info coroutine]]
yield
}
# A coroutine-based wait-for-some-time command
proc waittime ms {
after $ms [info coroutine]
yield
}
coroutine task-1 eval {
puts "waiting for a"
waitvar a
puts "a was set"
puts "setting b"
set b 42
}
coroutine task-2 eval {
waittime 500
puts "waiting for b"
waitvar b
puts "b was set"
set done ok
}
coroutine task-3 eval {
waittime 1000
puts "setting a"
set a 10
}
vwait done